Back to Blog
Comparison

Memberful vs. Skool: Monetize Content or Build Community?

We’re looking at Memberful and Skool, two tools for creators. One helps you sell subscriptions on your existing site, the other builds a community around your courses.

Memberful
vs
Skool

We often hear creators asking: should I focus on selling content directly, or build a community first? It’s a real fork in the road, and these two tools, Memberful and Skool, represent those different paths. We'll help you figure out which one fits your creative business.

Quick verdict

If you already have a website, a blog, or a podcast, and you want to start gating content and selling memberships right away, Memberful is likely your best bet. If you want to build a lively community around your courses or expertise, where engagement matters most, Skool pulls everything together nicely.

Features that actually matter

When we look at these platforms, we care about what helps us make money and serve our audience well. They both help us monetize, but they go about it very differently.

Memberful focuses on integrating subscriptions into your existing content. It lets you restrict access to posts, pages, or even private podcasts on your own site. We like that it keeps you in control of your content home.

Skool is built around the idea of a community hub. It gives you a discussion forum, hosts your courses, and even runs live calls all in one place. It’s a consolidated experience for your members, which can be great for engagement.

When it comes to courses, Memberful isn't built for that. You'd need another platform. Skool, however, has a "Classroom" for structured learning, but it’s pretty basic. Don't expect fancy quizzes or certificates.

Payment processing is another big difference. Memberful connects directly to Stripe, so you own that financial relationship. Skool also uses Stripe, but also PayPal. Memberful charges a percentage on top of monthly fees and Stripe's fees, which can add up quickly. Skool offers a flat monthly fee for its Pro plan.

Here’s a quick look at where they stand apart:

FeatureMemberfulSkool
Primary UseContent monetization, membership sellingCommunity building, course hosting
Content GatingRobust for existing websites (WordPress)Primarily for courses and community discussions
Course HostingNone, requires external toolsBasic "Classroom" with modules
CommunityRequires external tools (Discord, Discourse)Integrated discussion, live events, gamification
Monetization FeesHigh percentage + monthly fee + StripeFlat monthly fee for Pro plan + Stripe/PayPal
Data OwnershipStrong, direct Stripe connectionMember data and payments via platform, Stripe/PayPal

Pros and cons

We see clear advantages and disadvantages with each.

Memberful Pros:

  • We keep strong ownership of member data and direct payment relationships through Stripe.
  • Their customer support is excellent and responsive.
  • Setting it up is straightforward, especially when integrating with an existing website.
  • It has solid WordPress integration for protecting content on your server.

Memberful Cons:

  • The transaction fees are high, 4.9% on paid plans and 10% on the free plan, plus a monthly fee and Stripe's processing fees. This significantly cuts into our profits.
  • It doesn't have built-in email marketing, course creation, or comprehensive community management. We need other tools for those.
  • It only uses Stripe for payments, limiting options for some international customers or those preferring other methods like PayPal.
  • Branding and customization for checkout pages are limited and live on a Memberful subdomain.

Skool Pros:

  • The user interface is clean, intuitive, and simple, which really helps with member engagement.
  • It combines community and course hosting smoothly in one platform.
  • Their gamification system, with points, levels, and leaderboards, drives member activity and course completion.
  • The flat-rate pricing model for the Pro plan supports unlimited members and courses.

Skool Cons:

  • It lacks advanced course features, like built-in quizzes, certificates, drip content, or detailed student progress tracking.
  • Minimal branding and customization options.
  • It doesn't have comprehensive native marketing features like advanced checkout customization, upsells, or extensive email automation.
  • Its third-party integration ecosystem is thin, with shallow Zapier coverage and no native CRM.

Who should pick what

Let's consider a few scenarios for creators like us.

If you are a seasoned blogger with thousands of readers on your WordPress site and you want to offer exclusive articles, a private newsletter, or early access to content for a monthly fee, Memberful is your clear choice. You keep your existing site as your home base and just add a membership layer.

If you’re a coach launching a cohort-based program and want a central place for discussions, course modules, live Q&A sessions, and maybe even a bit of friendly competition among members, Skool makes a lot of sense. It provides the all-in-one hub you need for that experience.

If you publish a podcast and want to offer premium episodes or bonus content to paying subscribers without changing your hosting, Memberful easily integrates with your existing podcast RSS feed to gate content. You don't need a whole new platform; you just add a paywall.

Closing line

The right tool helps you serve your audience and grow your business; pick the one that aligns with your core offering.

Want the side-by-side comparison?
See Memberful vs Skool →

Get new posts in your inbox

Get a weekly teardown of how pros use these tools to add $$$ to their content businesses.

Enter your email
Subscribe